“Sangen Om Den Eldröda Blomman” ( “Song Of The Scarlet Flower” ) was a recent and remarkable silent surprise for this Herr Von; the oeuvre is an excellent Herr Stiller silent film that this German count watched in a newly restored and tinted copy. It combines the well-known aesthetics, technical improvements and artistic merits for which the Nordic director was known and praised since those early silent times till today.
The film tells of the merry and carefree love life of young Olof ( Herr Lars Hanson ) a woodsman who during his search for true love, seduces many frauleins ( just like this German aristocrat… well, not exactly because the purpose of this Herr Von’s seduction of rich fräulein heiresses are their great fortunes… ). He will suffer disappointment and deception, all those problems that turn up in any loving relationship. Finally he will find responsibility and maturity, learning during his particular quest that his actions always have consequences in different degrees to the people around him. This Herr Von can describe “Sangen Om…” as a kind of coming of age film, the special introspective growth toward maturity of a free and easy youngster.
As this German count said before, the film displays Stiller’s characteristic artistic virtues. ; in the first part of the film, we can see elements of comedy, not exactly like the comedy of intrigues in other Stiller films, but humor of a more cheerful sort, highlighting the self-involvement of our hero. Olof ‘s frivolous flirtations with the different girls eventually turn romantic and then turn into drama. There is conflict in the troubled relationship between Olof and his father and later with the father of his beloved. The beautiful and wild natural landscapes of Norrland and northern Sweden lend the tale a certain power and is characteristic of Herr Stiller’s other silents where Nature emerges as an important character in the story. This is strongly reflected throughout the film but especially during the frantic scene wherein Olof descends into the troubled waters of a river, a beautiful metaphor for the hardships that our hero has to endure until he finds himself.
“Sangen Om Den Eldröda Blomman” is an excellent, beautiful film, a solid, technically perfect and intricate production of 1919 that demonstrates once again the importance of Herr Stiller for silent film history.
个人非常无感这种反转再反转的剧情。除了反转本身，就很没意思。没意思程度相当于赵本山的脑筋急转弯和王建国的谐音梗。
彪叔像一根定海神针，牢牢的稳着整体节奏，这种角色感觉都不需要使劲就比张颂文的“刻意”来的更有功力了，从演技上窦骁绝对要感谢老爷子带得好，所有演员在这种黑色幽默的彪叔营造的调性下，都特别合适，没什么太大的问题
还是挺好的。一出小品式的黑色幽默。黑色喜剧元素，悬疑元素，动作元素都齐了，整体故事套路上并不很新颖，也没做到特别流畅，但也大致能自圆其说了，一波波转折层出不穷，草灰蛇线的线索也铺垫的比较足。剪辑上还不够好，欠点火候。表演上真的是挺不错的。范伟的表演还是一如既往的亲民有层次。影片后半段孩子们一出来，一下子主题升华了，让人有点感动，不错。
爆米花指数较高。完成度很高，包袱翻的也很响亮，范伟老师一如既往的优秀～ 刘翔加油！
刻意为之的黑色喜剧，黑色效果和喜剧效果都很牵强。用心了，但缺乏才华。
中式幽默，窦骁的人物力度展现的淋漓精致，好歹也是电影学院毕业的，他适合演坏人！！所以，人往往不要相信眼睛看到的。
7/10 一遍一遍回溯，故事越来越清晰，还可以吧
剧本杀，而且全员恶人。许多情节看似突兀，回想起来确实又交代过，想玩黑色幽默吧又不具备那个艺术细菌，新晋导演的牛刀小试，勉强及格了，6.0/10。
豆瓣這個分數還是差不多的，就是感覺導演確實花了心思在結構上，鏡頭上也挺講究，但是時長真的有點長了，只發生在一間房子裡，然後要靠不斷出現新人物加不斷重複閃回過去後加上一些新鏡頭來撐住時長。特別是最後等警察來真的有些搞笑了，真的是反派死於話多啊，都爆炸了，警察分分鐘就來了，還有心思解釋半天，雖然知道肯定是這個結尾，但還是太刻意了吧。而且確實是靠范偉的演技在撐著整部電影了。不過黑色幽默感還是挺強的，喜劇難拍，黑色幽默更難一些，就這點來看，導演拍的還行，中規中矩吧，不算佳片，但有閃光點
谁是好人谁是坏人，谁对谁错，谁生谁死，都在一念之间。多次反转，很精彩的片子。
预期以上，节奏感很好。结尾感觉可以更有意思一点。
差点意思，很青涩的作品，有点太炫技了。故事结构可以，故事的不同部分内容、转折粗糙了些
代入感很漂移，无聊到完全不care发生了什么，一帮孩子出来就不想看了。
预期以上，节奏感很好。结尾感觉可以更有意思一点。
剧情、悬疑还是可以的。范老师的表演有点出戏。结尾，是硬加上去的吧。
感觉差一口气，太想营造反转，但整个故事看完没能给人留下什么余韵
3.5 可真是比我和我的XXX系好，也比很多院线国产片好。
不断的反转，剧本杀，狭小空间，悬疑。
个人觉得这绝对是一部被低估的小成本国产电影！情节反转反转再反转，不看到最后绝对不知道发生了什么呀～～～人性啊～～～
打磨得很好的类型片，前3/4都很自洽，大多数钩子后的东西，人物的「不得不」都设计得意料之外情理之中。编剧用心，手艺不错，看得开心。
Copyright © 2015-2023 All Rights Reserved
